Disciple or Discipline?

Recently I read a blog that took an excerpt from the book Eight Secrets to Highly Effective Parenting by Scott Turansky, D.Min. and Joanne Miller, R.N., B.S.N. The passage compared running to disciplining children. The writers emphasize the primary goal of parenting to be teaching children to obey.  This doesn’t sit right with me, even though at one time in my young parenting I might have agreed with them.  They refer back to the Biblical 5th commandment of “Honor your father and mother. Then you will live a long full life in the land the Lord your God will give you.” (Exodus 20:12) The Apostle Paul also writes  “Children obey your parents”.  He also speaks to fathers and says:  “Do not exasperate your children.”  I propose that when we make obedience our goal in raising children we can very easily exasperate them, and even wound them, which would lead to all sorts of trouble for these children as well as trouble in our relationship with them.

If we look to the founder of our faith, Jesus, whose example Christians are meant to follow, I believe the goal of our parenting is love.  We are to teach and train our children to receive love and give love. Jesus emphasizes the two greatest commandments in which we are instructed to love God, others and ourselves. (Matthew 22:38-40) Jesus’ example in the gospels of receiving and blessing children, even rebuking his disciples when they harshly tried to keep them away from him, is the one I want to follow.  He delighted in them, blessed them and affirmed them.  He even honored them by teaching his disciples to become like them.  Jesus also taught us that if we love him, we will obey him.  So obedience flows from a heart full of love.  When I know him and love him, of course I want to please him and do what he asks of me.  I want to make his heart glad, put a smile on his face and make him proud of me.

As a Pastor, Healing Prayer Counselor and Parent Coach I have seen too many children and adults who have been wounded by this kind of harsh obedience orientated parenting, my own children included.  (Thank God they have forgiven me!) Instead I propose that we let love be our goal.  I am not saying this is easy or promoting a wishy-washy kind of permissive parenting where anything goes.  I am promoting engaged, creative parenting where we are committed to disciple our children, rather than merely discipline them.  As we teach and train with the long-term goal of raising loving children, they will become loving adults who respond to God’s love as well as love themselves and those around them.

Categories: Faith, God, Love, Parenting | Tags: , , , , , , | 6 Comments

Post navigation

6 thoughts on “Disciple or Discipline?

  1. Nathan Clark

    That’s really good Mater. I like how it’s all about love. That really sits right.

  2. jf

    I agree, Julie!
    Paul wrote (1 Tim 1:5) that the goal of our instruction is love from a pure heart and a good conscience and a sincere faith. I am glad God in Christ loves us enough to have come and laid down His life for His friends… which is what parents do, too, in different ways, to promote that love in our wee ones who grow up so wonderfully FAST (in retrospect!) and well (if we’re blessed — and we have been!).

  3. I found your blog by searching for articles on wordpress about discipline, and I really enjoyed reading what you wrote and found it to be encouraging. Thank you for writing it! I think it’s interesting that the command to obey parents is written to the children. God could have said to parents, “Make your children obey you, first time, all the time with a happy heart, ” but He didn’t do anything like that at all. Though we can make our children comply, we can’t make them obey, because true obedience comes from the heart. I like how you wrote, “So obedience flows from a heart full of love.”

    • Thank you for your comment! That is a good point about who Paul was addressing in that command. I just feel like it is way too narrow to make obedience our primary goal. It feels so harsh and joyless when raising children is such a great wonderous adventure where parents are learning and growing right along with their children.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at WordPress.com.

%d bloggers like this: